I once planned a program the way a nervous climber studies a route from the ground: every hold mapped, every move in sequence. I set the order of sessions so the story built from one to the next. I briefed each facilitator on what came before them and what came after.
Then a cyclone closed one of the venues, flights were cancelled, and by the time we could reschedule a month later, the facilitators weren’t available, and the opening of the program had to be rebuilt on the fly.
The plan was meticulous, but the real world had other ideas.
That’s the tension in every capability investment. You need a plan, but what you’re really building is people who can keep climbing when the route changes.
The Wall: Where skills are built safely
Most climbers start indoors. The holds are colour-coded, the routes are marked, and there’s a crash mat underneath. It’s where you learn the basics without the cost of falling.
In capability building, the wall is the workshop, the simulation, the practice session. It’s necessary. The trouble is that many programs treat it as the destination. People leave the gym confident, then meet real rock with no idea where the holds are.
Graded Routes: Difficulty, step-by-step
Good climbing gyms grade their routes, so you progress from easy to hard deliberately. Each route is a complete climb, only slightly harder than the last.
Capability works the same way. Start with real tasks in simple form, then add complexity: more ambiguity, higher stakes, less support. By the time people reach the rock, they’ve already climbed something close to it.
Rock Face: Where it counts
Outdoors, nothing is marked and conditions change. This is where capability is tested under real pressure.
I worked with a group of health leaders who handled the graded routes well. They trialled new processes, refined them and were open to new ways of working. Then the change was rolled out across the whole workforce at once, and critical gaps appeared. The story of why the change mattered to individuals was missing. There were no individual coaching conversations to help leaders support each person through it. And the rollout treated a diverse workforce as though it would respond in one way... It didn’t.
On reflection and using this current metaphor, it was like sending every climber up the same route regardless of reach, strength, or fear of heights.
Belayer: Who holds the rope?
In roped climbing, nobody should climb without a belayer: someone holding the rope who catches you when you slip and lets you attempt harder moves.
At work, that’s often the manager, but it can also be a peer, coach or sponsor. What matters is that someone is actively holding the line while people practise. A meta-analysis of 89 studies by Blume and colleagues found that a supportive work environment was positively associated with whether new skills transferred into work. A later meta-analysis by Reinhold and colleagues found that peer support was the strongest predictor of people’s motivation to use new skills, and feedback and coaching were the strongest predictor of whether they actually did.
Models such as Prosci’s ADKAR offer a useful checklist for spotting what a rollout may have missed. It sets out five things individuals need to change: awareness of why, desire to change, knowledge, ability and reinforcement. In ADKAR terms, the health rollout may have assumed knowledge and ability while giving too little attention to awareness, desire and reinforcement. That’s where the belayer’s work happens.
A checklist isn’t a guarantee, though. No model replaces judgement about the specific change, workforce and context. Read the rock before you choose the next move.
Five checks…
Do people understand why this matters to them, not just to the organisation?
Can they do it on the wall, in practice, with feedback?
Can they do it on a harder route, with real tasks and less help?
Who’s holding the rope at work, and do they know that’s part of their job?
What will we watch for on the rock face to know the change has held?
If you can’t answer one of these, that’s where your next investment belongs! If you’re unsure, reach out to Plexity.
Where Plexity fits
I sit independently on the buyer’s side, with no training product to sell. I help leaders read the rock before they commit: where people are starting from, how far the wall needs to go, and who will be holding the rope once the program ends.
References
Blume, B. D., Ford, J. K., Baldwin, T. T., & Huang, J. L. (2010). Transfer of training: A meta-analytic review. Journal of Management, 36(4), 1065–1105. https://doi.org/10.1177/0149206309352880
Hiatt, J. M. (2006). ADKAR: A model for change in business, government and our community. Prosci.
Reinhold, S., Gegenfurtner, A., & Lewalter, D. (2018). Social support and motivation to transfer as predictors of training transfer: Testing full and partial mediation using meta-analytic structural equation modelling. International Journal of Training and Development, 22(1), 1–14. https://doi.org/10.1111/ijtd.12115